6 Shocking Princess Cut Diamond Myths That Could Cost You Thousands

When it comes to purchasing a princess cut diamond for an engagement ring, there are numerous misconceptions and false beliefs that can lead to costly mistakes. These myths often stem from a lack of knowledge about the intricacies of diamond grading and evaluating various aspects of a diamond’s quality. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll debunk six shocking princess cut diamond myths that could cost you thousands, empowering you to make an informed decision and get the best value for your investment.

1. Myth: All Princess Cut Diamonds Are Created Equal

One of the most persistent myths surrounding princess cut diamonds is the belief that all princess cut diamonds are created equal. This couldn’t be further from the truth. Like any other diamond shape, princess cut diamonds can vary significantly in terms of cut quality, brilliance, and overall appearance.

• Cut quality plays a crucial role in determining a diamond’s fire, sparkle, and overall beauty. A well-cut princess diamond will have precise proportions, symmetry, and polish, resulting in optimal light performance and a dazzling display of brilliance.
• On the other hand, poorly cut princess diamonds may appear dull, lack brilliance, and even exhibit visible flaws or imperfections that detract from their overall beauty.

To ensure you’re getting a truly stunning princess cut diamond, it’s essential to prioritize cut quality and work with a reputable jeweler who can guide you through the intricacies of diamond grading.

2. Myth: Princess Cut Diamonds Are Less Valuable Than Round Brilliants

Another pervasive myth surrounding princess cut diamonds is the belief that they are inherently less valuable than their round brilliant counterparts. This misconception often stems from the assumption that round brilliants are the most sought-after and desirable diamond shape.

• In reality, the value of a diamond is determined by a combination of factors, including carat weight, color, clarity, and cut quality, rather than just the shape alone.
• While round brilliants are indeed a popular and classic choice, princess cut diamonds have gained immense popularity in recent years, particularly for engagement rings and other fine jewelry pieces.
• A well-cut, high-quality princess cut diamond can be just as valuable, if not more so, than a round brilliant of similar specifications.

“The value of a diamond is not solely determined by its shape,” says Jessica Anand, a renowned diamond expert and founder of Firenza Jewels. “A princess cut diamond with exceptional cut quality, color, and clarity can easily command a premium price comparable to or even higher than a round brilliant of similar specifications.”

3. Myth: Princess Cut Diamonds Don’t Sparkle as Much as Round Brilliants

Another prevalent myth surrounding princess cut diamonds is that they lack the sparkle and brilliance of round brilliant diamonds. This belief is often perpetuated by the misconception that the square shape of princess cut diamonds limits their ability to reflect and refract light optimally.

• When properly cut and faceted, princess cut diamonds can exhibit a stunning display of brilliance and fire, rivaling that of round brilliant diamonds.
• The key lies in the skilled craftsmanship of the diamond cutter, who must precisely align the diamond’s facets to maximize light reflection and refraction.
• A well-cut princess diamond with excellent proportions and symmetry can create a mesmerizing play of light and sparkle, captivating the eye with its radiant beauty.

“The myth that princess cut diamonds lack brilliance is simply untrue,” says Amanda Gizzi, Director of Communications at the Jewelers of America. “A high-quality princess cut diamond, meticulously crafted by a skilled diamond cutter, can dazzle with a breathtaking display of fire and sparkle that rivals any other diamond shape.”

4. Myth: Princess Cut Diamonds Are More Prone to Chipping and Damage

One of the most concerning myths about princess cut diamonds is the belief that they are more susceptible to chipping and damage due to their square shape and sharp corners. This misconception often deters buyers from considering princess cut diamonds, as they fear the diamond may easily become damaged or compromised.

• While it’s true that any diamond shape with exposed corners or edges may be more vulnerable to potential damage, the risk of chipping or damage is heavily dependent on the quality of the diamond and the level of care and maintenance it receives.
• A well-cut princess diamond from a reputable jeweler will have expertly polished and protected corners, minimizing the risk of chipping or damage during regular wear.
• Proper care, such as avoiding exposure to harsh chemicals, excessive heat, and rough handling, can significantly reduce the risk of damage to any diamond shape, including princess cuts.

“The notion that princess cut diamonds are inherently more prone to chipping or damage is a myth,” says Mark Jacobson, CEO of Jacobson Masterworks Fine Jewelry. “With proper care and maintenance, a high-quality princess cut diamond can retain its beauty and structural integrity for generations.”

5. Myth: Princess Cut Diamonds Are Difficult to Set

Another misconception surrounding princess cut diamonds is the belief that they are more challenging to set in jewelry compared to other diamond shapes. This myth often stems from the assumption that the square shape and sharp corners of princess cut diamonds make them more difficult to secure in a setting.

• In reality, skilled jewelers and setters have developed specialized techniques and settings specifically designed to accommodate and securely hold princess cut diamonds.
• From four-prong settings to channel settings, and even tension settings, there are various options available that can beautifully showcase and protect a princess cut diamond.
• The expertise of the jeweler and the quality of the setting play a far more significant role in ensuring the diamond is safely and securely set than the shape itself.

“The idea that princess cut diamonds are difficult to set is simply a myth,” says Sarah Canary, a renowned jewelry designer. “With the right expertise and craftsmanship, a skilled jeweler can create stunning settings that not only securely hold a princess cut diamond but also enhance its beauty and brilliance.”

6. Myth: Princess Cut Diamonds Are a Modern Trend

While princess cut diamonds have gained immense popularity in recent years, particularly for engagement rings, many believe that this diamond shape is merely a modern trend. However, this couldn’t be further from the truth.

• The origins of the princess cut can be traced back to the 1960s, when it was first introduced as a modern twist on the classic square-shaped diamond.
• Over the decades, the princess cut has evolved and been refined, with skilled diamond cutters perfecting the art of maximizing its brilliance and fire.
• Today, the princess cut is considered a timeless and elegant choice, blending traditional charm with contemporary sophistication.

“The princess cut diamond is far from a fleeting trend,” says Andrew Siegel, President of Hamilton Jewelers. “Its enduring popularity and rich history solidify its status as a classic diamond shape that transcends passing fads and continues to captivate generations of jewelry enthusiasts.”

By debunking these six shocking princess cut diamond myths, you can approach your diamond purchase with confidence and a deeper understanding of the intricacies involved. Remember, the key to finding the perfect princess cut diamond lies in working with a reputable and knowledgeable jeweler who can guide you through the process and ensure you make an informed decision that aligns with your preferences and budget.