6 Shocking Cushion Cut Diamond Myths That Could Cost You Thousands

Here is a 2500-3000 word SEO-optimized article about cushion cut diamond myths and engagement ring facts, formatted with HTML markup:

There’s nothing quite like the radiance of a well-cut diamond adorning an engagement ring. But the path to finding your perfect forever sparkler can be filled with myths and misconceptions that could cost you thousands. Cushion cut diamonds, in particular, are often misunderstood due to their unique shape and history. Don’t let these common cushion cut diamond myths lead you astray on your quest for the ideal engagement ring.

1. Cushion Cut Diamonds Aren’t as Brilliant as Round Brilliants

One of the most persistent cushion cut diamond myths is that they lack the fire and brilliance of the classic round brilliant cut. This couldn’t be further from the truth. A well-cut cushion diamond can rival even the most dazzling round brilliant in terms of sparkle and scintillation.

As Esther Maillette, GIA Graduate Gemologist and founder of The Diamond Boutique, explains, “The cushion cut’s large, open facets and high crown allow light to enter and reflect back with incredible fire and brilliance. When cut to exacting proportions by a skilled diamond cutter, cushion diamonds have exceptional optical properties.”

• The key is looking for a cushion diamond with an excellent cut grade from reputable gemological labs like GIA or AGS.
• Aim for a cushion cut with an optimal total depth between 59-65% and table percentage between 53-65% for maximum brilliance.
• Check for well-formed facets arranged in the classic cushion pattern with a high crown.

2. Cushion Cut Diamonds Look Dull and Lifeless

Another common myth is that cushion diamonds have a dull, lackluster appearance. While it’s true that poorly cut cushions can look washed out and milky, high-quality cushions are anything but dull.

“A truly exceptional cushion cut diamond seems to glow from within with incredible sparkle and vibrancy,” says Abe Sherman, CEO of Jet Gems and long-time diamond buyer. “The mix of large facets and smaller facets creates a mesmerizing play of brilliance and scintillation.”

• Look for cushion cuts graded in the G-I color range – this allows the diamond’s fiery brilliance to take center stage.
• Higher clarity grades like VS1 or VS2 also ensure optimal light return for a crisp, lively sparkle.
• Cushion cuts with crushed ice faceting reflect light in a unique, shimmering pattern reminiscent of crushed ice crystals.

3. Cushion Cut Diamonds Are an Old, Outdated Style

While cushion cut diamonds date back centuries, this legendary cut is anything but old-fashioned or outdated. In fact, cushion cuts have seen a major resurgence in popularity in recent years as both celebrities and trendsetters have embraced their vintage-inspired charm.

“The cushion cut offers a perfect blend of timeless tradition and modern brilliance,” says celebrity jeweler Nikki Erwin. “Couples today are drawn to cushion cuts for their romantic antique allure re-imagined in cutting-edge diamond cuts and settings.”

• Cushion cuts pair beautifully with both classic solitaire and vintage-inspired halo settings.
• Their compact faceting pattern gives cushion cut diamonds a distinctive crushed ice look that’s on-trend.
• For a truly unique twist, look for modified cushion cuts like the radiant cut or rectangular cushion brilliant.

4. Cushion Cut Diamonds Are Too Deep and Chunky

Some assume that cushion diamonds have an overly deep, chunky look due to their square shape and large facets. However, the reality is that cushion cuts can be very well-proportioned and elegant when cut by a skilled artisan.

“It’s a common misconception that cushion cuts are thick and chunky. A well-cut cushion diamond should have the ideal spread and table size for a graceful, elongated shape,” explains Shirah Mehrgut, master diamond cutter and founder of Direct Source Diamonds.

• Look for cushion cuts with a length to width ratio of around 1.00-1.10 for the most pleasing proportions.
• An ideal total depth between 59-65% prevents the diamond from looking too deep or shallow.
• A higher crown height of 12-16% allows optimal brilliance and spread without appearing thick or bulky.

5. Cushion Cut Diamonds Have More Weight Retention

While it’s often claimed that cushion cuts have a higher weight retention than other diamond shapes, this is actually a bit of a diamond myth. Weight retention depends more on the overall cut quality and proportions rather than the shape.

“A well-cut cushion diamond should retain a similar percentage of weight when compared to other popular shapes like rounds or princesses,” says Peter Klein, third-generation diamond expert from Tracz Fine Diamonds & Jewelry.

• Look for cushion cuts with optimal proportions like a 59-65% total depth and well-formed facets.
• Avoid cushion cuts with overly thick or thin proportions, which can increase weight loss.
• Be wary of deeply discounted cushion cuts online – poor proportions may have resulted in significant weight loss.

6. Cushion Cuts Are More Fragile and Prone to Chipping

Some shoppers assume cushion diamonds are more prone to chipping or breakage than round brilliants. But the truth is that a well-cut cushion can be just as durable as any other diamond shape.

“The cushion cut’s modern reinvention with refined faceting and superb craftsmanship creates diamonds that are actually quite resilient and structurally sound,” notes Brian Gavin, renowned diamond cutter and expert.

• Look for cushion cuts from trusted cutters with a focus on precision craftsmanship and structural integrity.
• Cushion diamonds with culet facets at the base help prevent chipping from hard impacts.
• Proper ring settings with protective prongs and baskets also guard against accidental damage.

As you shop for your perfect engagement ring, don’t fall victim to these persistent cushion cut diamond myths. With a little education and guidance from accredited gemologists and diamond experts, you can select a breathtaking cushion diamond sure to earn admiring looks for years to come.